Secret Societies: History, Purpose and Influence

From the mysteries of Eleusis to student societies at Yale: why people have gathered in secret, and what they actually achieved.

Published

Secret societies have existed in almost every period and region of history. Some protected a persecuted faith, some prepared revolutions, some offered mutual aid, and many simply gave their members a sense of belonging through shared ritual. Their influence has often been exaggerated, but it has also been real. This article explains what secret societies are and why they form, surveys historical secret societies across the world, and separates their documented influence from later legend.

What are secret societies?

A secret society is an organization that keeps some part of its life hidden from outsiders. The question is always what is hidden. Historians usually distinguish three levels of secrecy:

  1. Hidden existence. The society itself is unknown to outsiders. This is rare and usually happens under persecution or in political conspiracies.
  2. Hidden membership. The society is known, but its members are not.
  3. Hidden rituals. The society, its meeting places and many members are public. Only its ceremonies, teachings and modes of recognition are kept private.

Most organizations that people call secret societies belong to the third group. For the sociology of secrecy, and how it binds members together, see Illuminati Members and Secret Societies.

Why secret societies form

The historical record suggests five recurring reasons:

Historical secret societies around the world

Ancient mystery cults: Eleusis and Mithras

The Eleusinian Mysteries, held at Eleusis near Athens in honour of Demeter and Persephone, are attested from the seventh century BC until the late fourth century AD. Thousands of people were initiated, including slaves and foreigners, yet initiates were forbidden to reveal the central rites. They kept the secret so well that historians still do not know exactly what happened in the hall of initiation.

The cult of Mithras spread through the Roman Empire from the first to the fourth century AD, especially among soldiers and officials. Its members met in small underground chambers, called mithraea, and advanced through seven grades, from Raven to Father, which are documented in inscriptions and mosaics, notably at Ostia near Rome.

The Pythagoreans

In southern Italy around 530 BC, the philosopher Pythagoras founded a community at Croton that combined philosophy, mathematics and a disciplined way of life. Later ancient writers describe rules of silence and secrecy about its teachings. Because most of these accounts were written centuries afterwards, historians treat their details with caution.

The Hidden Christians of Japan

After Japan banned Christianity in 1614, communities in the Nagasaki region continued to practise their faith in secret for more than two centuries. They handed down prayers orally, disguised Christian images as Buddhist ones, and organized themselves under lay leaders. In 1865 some of them revealed their faith to a French missionary at the newly built Ōura Church in Nagasaki, and the ban was lifted in 1873. Their sites were inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2018 as the Hidden Christian Sites in the Nagasaki Region. It is one of history’s clearest examples of religious secrecy as survival.

The Heaven and Earth Society in China

The Tiandihui, or Heaven and Earth Society, was founded in Fujian province in about 1761–1762. The historians Dian Murray and Qin Baoqi have shown that it began as a mutual-aid brotherhood for men who lacked family support, bound by blood oaths and initiation ceremonies. Anti-dynastic slogans, such as the call to restore the Ming dynasty, were added later. Societies descended from it spread with Chinese emigrants across Southeast Asia and beyond.

Poro and Sande in West Africa

In Sierra Leone, Liberia and neighbouring regions, the Poro society for men and the Sande society for women have long organized initiation into adult life. Initiates learn skills, values and knowledge kept from the uninitiated. These societies have also helped regulate community life. The Sande society is notable for its carved helmet masks, which are worn by women in ceremonies. That is rare in African masking traditions, in which masks are usually worn by men.

Enlightenment Europe

Eighteenth-century Europe saw an explosion of private societies. The largest was Freemasonry; see Freemasonry and Freemasons. The Bavarian Illuminati (1776–1785) was a smaller, more secretive reform society that recruited within Masonic lodges; see The Illuminati Secret Society. Rosicrucian orders offered a mystical alternative. These societies are covered in detail elsewhere on this site.

Political secret societies of the nineteenth century

Some of the clearest cases of real influence come from national independence movements:

American fraternal and student societies

In the United States, secret and semi-secret societies became part of everyday life:

Esoteric orders

The Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, founded in London in 1888, taught ritual magic, astrology and mystical philosophy through a system of grades. The poet W. B. Yeats was a member. Its influence on later Western esotericism was considerable, although the order itself split apart within about fifteen years.

Four kinds of secret society

Historians often classify secret societies by their main purpose. Many societies combine several.

Purpose Aim Examples
Religious Protect or practise a faith, or offer salvation through initiation Eleusinian Mysteries, Mithras, Hidden Christians of Japan
Philosophical and esoteric Teach a philosophy or hidden wisdom in stages Pythagoreans, Rosicrucians, Golden Dawn
Fraternal and mutual aid Fellowship, moral teaching and support for members Freemasonry, Odd Fellows, early Tiandihui
Political Organize change against an existing government Filiki Eteria, Carbonari, Irish Republican Brotherhood

Membership, symbols and traditions

Despite their variety, secret societies share common patterns:

Secret societies, private associations and fraternal organizations

The term “secret society” is often applied too broadly. The differences are mainly about what is hidden, and from whom:

Type What is public What is private Examples
Secret society Little or nothing Existence, membership or aims Filiki Eteria, Irish Republican Brotherhood, Bavarian Illuminati
Fraternal organization Existence, meeting places, charity, many members Ceremonies and recognition signs Freemasonry, Odd Fellows
Private association Existence and purpose Internal discussions and membership lists Private clubs, professional bodies, student societies

An organization can also move between categories. Phi Beta Kappa began as a secret society and became a public honour society. Freemasons often describe their fraternity as “not a secret society but a society with secrets”.

The historical influence of secret societies

Documented influence

The record shows real but specific forms of influence:

Exaggerated influence

Influence has also been greatly overstated. The Knights Templar were a public military order, suppressed by Pope Clement V in 1312, yet later legends turned them into the hidden ancestors of many secret societies. The Bavarian Illuminati was active for less than a decade, but it was later blamed for the French Revolution and much else. Neither claim is supported by historical evidence.

The pattern is consistent: the less that is known about a society, the more influence is attributed to it. This is one reason secret societies feature in New World Order theories, which treat secrecy itself as proof of power.

Secret societies FAQ

What is a secret society?

An organization that keeps some part of its life hidden from outsiders, such as its existence, membership, aims or rituals. Most well-known examples keep only their ceremonies private.

What are some famous secret societies?

Famous historical examples include the Eleusinian Mysteries, the cult of Mithras, the Pythagoreans, the Freemasons, the Bavarian Illuminati, the Carbonari, the Filiki Eteria, the Irish Republican Brotherhood and Skull and Bones.

Why do secret societies use symbols?

Symbols give members a shared language, teach moral or spiritual lessons in compact form, and mark a sense of belonging. Many come from a craft, a myth or a sacred text.

Is Freemasonry a secret society?

Freemasonry is better described as a fraternal organization with private ceremonies. Its existence, lodges, charities and many members are public. See Freemasonry and Freemasons.

Do secret societies still exist?

Yes. Fraternal orders, student societies and religious and esoteric groups with private rituals exist today. Most operate openly and keep only their ceremonies private.

Conclusion

Secret societies are a recurring part of human history, not a single hidden network. They have protected the persecuted, organized revolutions, supported members in hard times and given people ritual and belonging. Studying them through their own records shows both their real achievements and how easily secrecy turns into legend.

Sources