The Illuminati and the Jesuits

The Bavarian Illuminati was founded against the Jesuits, copied some of their methods, and called them its 'worst enemies' in cipher. Both orders were later accused of the same kind of secret plot.

Published

The Jesuits and the Illuminati are often mentioned together, sometimes as enemies, sometimes as two faces of the same hidden power. The historical relationship is well documented, because the Illuminati wrote about the Jesuits constantly in letters that the Bavarian government seized and printed in 1787. Those letters show rivalry, imitation and fear, but no alliance.

This article sets out what the order’s own papers say about the Jesuits, how both societies became targets of conspiracy theories, and why the claim that the Jesuits created the Illuminati reverses the evidence. Adam Weishaupt’s Jesuit schooling and career are covered in Adam Weishaupt.

The Illuminati and the Jesuits at a glance

Question What the evidence shows
Was Weishaupt connected with the Jesuits? He was educated at the Jesuit college in Ingolstadt and became one of their sharpest critics.
Did the Illuminati copy the Jesuits? In part: discipline, reports to superiors and graded training. Critics inside the order said so at the time.
How did the order see the Jesuits? As its “worst enemies”, a phrase Weishaupt wrote in the order’s cipher in 1779.
Could ex-Jesuits join? No. An instruction for the order’s leaders says ex-Jesuits should be shunned “like the plague”.
Did the Jesuits create the Illuminati? No document suggests it. The order was founded and run against them.

Ex-Jesuits in Weishaupt’s Bavaria

Pope Clement XIV dissolved the Society of Jesus in 1773, three years before Weishaupt founded his order in Ingolstadt on 1 May 1776. Dissolution did not remove the former Jesuits. Many stayed in Bavaria as priests, teachers and advisers, and they remained a powerful party at the University of Ingolstadt and in the Church. When the Illuminati wrote about “the Jesuits” in the late 1770s and 1780s, they meant these former members and their allies, not a functioning order. The Society of Jesus was not restored until 1814.

The Illuminati saw them as the main obstacle to Enlightenment in Bavaria: the defenders of censorship, scholastic teaching and clerical control of education. The order’s wider attitude to the Church is discussed in Illuminati and Religion.

“Our worst enemies”: the order’s letters

The papers printed in 1787 as Einige Originalschriften des Illuminatenordens contain some of the clearest evidence.

In a letter signed “Spartacus”, Weishaupt’s code name, and dated “Eleusis, 30 Dimeh 1148” (Ingolstadt, 30 January 1779, in the order’s Persian calendar), Weishaupt asks whether the order could not play a similar trick on “unsern ärgsten Feinden, den 4.8.18.20.4.19.8.13”. In the order’s number cipher those figures spell IESUITEN: “our worst enemies, the Jesuits”. The cipher and calendar are explained in Illuminati Secret Codes.

The same letter is a cry of alarm about the university. “Never were the Jesuits as powerful as now; everything here is in their hands,” Weishaupt writes. Persecution and intrigue against those who think differently “grow stronger from day to day”. Four professors, Scholliner, Steigenberger, Wurzer and Schlegel, had been sent back to their monasteries, and only four of his own party remained to resist “the Jesuitism breaking in violently on all sides”. He had also heard rumours that they meant to have him moved away to Heidelberg.

The letter matters because it shows how the founder of the Illuminati understood his own position: not as the head of a powerful conspiracy, but as one of a few embattled reformers facing a stronger opponent.

Rules against Jesuits

The order turned that hostility into policy.

The same instructions told the order’s leaders to win over the heads of seminaries, because the clergy were “the most powerful opponents of every good plan”. The Illuminati wanted influence over religious education, but it wanted it in its own hands, not in Jesuit ones.

The order’s claimed victories

Among the papers seized in 1786 was a report in Zwackh’s handwriting on the order’s “progress in political matters” over one year. Two of its points concern the Jesuits:

These are the order’s own claims about itself, in an undated internal report. They show what its leaders wanted to believe they had achieved, and they became damaging evidence once printed: to its enemies, they proved that a secret society had been steering appointments and public money.

Borrowing the enemy’s methods

The rivalry had a famous irony. Weishaupt had been trained by the Jesuits and borrowed from them: discipline, a chain of superiors, regular confidential reports, and gradual instruction of members. Historians have long noted the debt, as described in The Illuminati Secret Society.

Members noticed it too. In letters to Zwackh of early 1783, quoted by the anonymous editor of the 1793 collection Die neuesten Arbeiten des Spartacus und Philo, Adolph Knigge (“Philo”) complained, in the editor’s summary, of Weishaupt’s “Jesuitical character” and of a yoke “worse than the yoke of the Jesuits”. When Knigge left the order in 1784, he accused Weishaupt of Jesuit-style despotism; see Famous Illuminati Members.

Knigge’s anti-Jesuit pamphlet and the “crypto-Jesuit” panic

Knigge also attacked the Jesuits in print. In 1781 he published, under the name “Joseph Aloisius Maier”, presented as a former Jesuit, a pamphlet titled Über Jesuiten, Freymaurer und deutsche Rosenkreuzer (“On Jesuits, Freemasons and German Rosicrucians”). In the same 1783 letters he boasted that he had “undermined the Strict Observance”, a rival Masonic system, and “wrote against Jesuits and Rosicrucians who had never offended me”.

The 1793 editor drew a striking conclusion. In Knigge’s pamphlet, he wrote, “the first seed was sown” of a claim that later caused great uproar: that Jesuits were hiding behind Protestants, trying to convert Protestant princes, and that secret Jesuits were concealed even among Protestant theologians. That is the editor’s judgement, not an established fact. But the fear he described was real.

In Berlin in the mid-1780s, leading Enlightenment writers, among them Friedrich Nicolai and the editors of the Berlinische Monatsschrift, Johann Erich Biester and Friedrich Gedike, warned of “crypto-Catholicism”: hidden Catholic and Jesuit influence inside Protestant society and its secret societies. The best-known case involved Johann August Starck, a senior Protestant court preacher at Darmstadt and an active Freemason, whom the Berlinische Monatsschrift accused of secret Catholicism. Starck sued, the Berlin court (Kammergericht) gave its judgment in August 1787, and Starck published his own reply in 1787, Über Krypto-Katholicismus, Proselytenmacherey, Jesuitismus, geheime Gesellschaften.

In other words, by the late 1780s Enlightenment writers feared a hidden Jesuit network at the same moment as their opponents were beginning to fear a hidden Illuminati network.

The same accusation, turned around

The Jesuits had been the target of secret-plot theories long before the Illuminati existed. The best-known example is the Monita Secreta, a supposed set of secret instructions for expanding Jesuit power, printed in Kraków in the 1610s. Scholars generally regard it as an anti-Jesuit forgery, attributed to Hieronim Zahorowski, a former Jesuit expelled from the Society. It was placed on the Catholic Church’s Index of Forbidden Books in 1616, but it was reprinted for centuries.

After the French Revolution the pattern was turned against the Jesuits’ enemies. The most influential author of the Illuminati conspiracy theory, Augustin Barruel, was a French priest who had joined the Jesuits before their suppression. His Mémoires pour servir à l’histoire du jacobinisme (1797–1798) blamed philosophers, Freemasons and the Illuminati for the Revolution. A society founded to resist Jesuit influence was thus made famous as a world conspiracy by a former Jesuit. The rest of that story is told in Illuminati Conspiracy Theories.

Were the Illuminati a Jesuit creation?

No. Weishaupt’s Jesuit schooling is sometimes presented as a clue that the Jesuits secretly founded or directed his order. The documents point the other way:

Similarity of method is not evidence of control. Many organizations of the period, including Freemasonry, armies and the Church itself, used ranks, reports and graded instruction.

The Illuminati and the Jesuits FAQ

What was the relationship between the Illuminati and the Jesuits?

Rivalry. The Bavarian Illuminati was founded in 1776 to spread Enlightenment ideas against the influence of the clergy, and above all of the former Jesuits who still dominated education in Bavaria. Its letters call them “our worst enemies”, and its rules excluded them.

Was Adam Weishaupt a Jesuit?

No. He was educated at the Jesuit college in Ingolstadt but did not join the Society of Jesus. He became a lay professor of canon law in 1773 and one of the Jesuits’ leading critics.

Because both were secret or semi-secret, centralised and disciplined, both were accused of hidden plots, and Weishaupt borrowed some Jesuit methods. The Illuminati conspiracy theory itself was popularised by a former Jesuit, Augustin Barruel.

In short: the Bavarian Illuminati defined itself against the Jesuits. Its founder called them “our worst enemies” in cipher, its rules excluded them, and its reports boasted of pushing them out of the university. Both orders were later cast as secret world conspiracies, but the documents show rivals, not allies.

Related: Adam Weishaupt · Illuminati and Religion · Illuminati Conspiracy Theories · History of the Illuminati

Sources